Appetizers
Best Quesadilla 22
You’ve Ever Had in Your Life Quesadilla
Our version of the classic chicken quesadilla. Blackened chicken, queso, sautéed onions, and jalapeños. Served with lettuce, salsa, and sour cream. Substitute with shrimp
AMI Island Wings 18
10 large chicken wings tossed in our house-made wing sauce. Served with ranch or blue cheese. Substitute with BBQ, sweet Thai chili, or buffalo
Grouper Nugget App 24
Fresh grouper battered in our blend of
herbs and spices, deep fried, and served with tartar sauce.
Colossal Calamari 22
A full pound of hand-breaded calamari served with our house-made dyno sauce.
Coconut Shrimp App 22
6 large butterflied shrimp fried with a coconut batter and served with our piña colada sauce.
Ugly Nachos 18
Your choice of pulled pork or chicken, house-made tortilla chips, layers of melted cheese, topped with queso, shredded lettuce, jalapeños, salsa, and sour cream.
Crab Stuffed Shrimp 28
Crab-topped jumbo shrimp with a savory garlic parmesan cheese sauce. Served
on a Tribeca baguette.
Chips & Queso 13
Fried house-made tortilla chips served with queso and fresh house-made salsa.
Grouper Kabobs App 28
Three kabobs loaded with fresh
grouper, onion, bell peppers, and
pineapple. Served with mango chili sauce.
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail 24
Jumbo shrimp served with our
signature “Ugly” cocktail sauce.
Crab Green Tomatoes 21
Fried green tomatoes topped with lump
crab and drizzled with our
house-made Cajun remoulade.
Seared Ahi Tuna 26
Fresh seared ahi tuna paired with
a crisp cabbage, carrot, and cucumber slaw, finished with a touch of ginger.
Ugly Cheese Logs 15
Made like no other—a must-try for fried cheese lovers. Served with ranch and marinara.
Chicken Chunks 22
A full pound of deep-fried boneless chicken tenderloin chunks. Served with your choice of wing sauce and ranch or blue cheese.
Goliath Pub Pretzel 17
A giant Bavarian-style pretzel, oven-baked, buttered, and salted. Choose two sauces: queso, honey mustard, or ranch.
Soups and Salads
Costal Clam Chowder
Cup 6, Bowl 8
Ocean clams, parsley, potatoes, and our house blend of spices.
AMI Greens Salad
Small 7, Large 12
Romaine salad blend, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onion. Topped with purple cabbage, carrots, and choice of dressing.
Classic Ceasar Salad
Small 7, Large 12
Romaine, herbed croutons, and grated parmesan lightly tossed.
Seafood Cobb Salad 24
Romaine topped with blue cheese crumbles, fried shrimp, bacon, hard-boiled egg, and tomatoes. Choice of dressing. Available as a chicken cobb.
Protein add-on
Chicken 9, Shrimp 13, Mahi 15,
Salmon 17, Grouper 19.
Dressings
Thousand island, honey mustard, ranch, blue cheese, balsamic vinaigrette, or italian.
Sandwiches
All sandwiches are served with fries and coleslaw.
Angus Burger 18
Half-pound Angus beef patty served on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, and choice of cheese.
Smokehouse Patty Melt 22 Signature Angus burger patty topped with house-made pulled pork and a choice of cheese. Served on Texas toast.
Island Chicken Sandwich 24
Fried chicken breast topped with pepper jack, bacon, grilled pineapple, lettuce, tomato, and pickle. Served with pineapple coleslaw and mango aioli on Texas toast.
Pulled Pork Sliders 20
Slow cooked pork topped with pineapple coleslaw and pickles on brioche slider buns. Served with our house-made bbq sauce.
Sides
French Fries, Mashed Potatoes, Coleslaw, Seasonal Vegetables, Caribbean Rice
Add Ons
Gluten-free bun 3, Bacon 3,
Jalapenos 2, Sauteed onion 2
Entrees
Fish and Chips 24
12 oz lightly battered cod served with fries and house-made tartar sauce.
Pesto Shrimp Cavatappi 29
Sautéed Blackened shrimp in
a creamy basil pesto sauce.
Served over cavatappi.
Thai Chili Salmon 34
Blackened, grilled, or fried Thai chili glazed salmon. Served with rice and seasonal vegetables.
Coconut Shrimp Dinner 32
8 large butterflied shrimp fried with coconut batter and served with piña colada sauce. Choice of two sides.
Fried Shrimp Dinner 32
12 large shrimp fried to perfection. Served with our cocktail sauce, and
choice of two sides.
Our Famous Grouper
Grouper Sandwich 25
Blackened, grilled, or fried grouper filet on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, and house-made Cajun remoulade. Served with choice of side.
Voted #1 grouper sandwich
Grouper Reuben 25
Grouper filet on sourdough or rye with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and thousand island dressing. Served with choice of side.
Blackened Grouper Kabobs 32
Three kabobs with grouper, onion, red peppers, and pineapple. Served with mango chili sauce and choice of two sides.
Grouper Tacos 26
Blackened grouper with cabbage and fresh salsa in signature cheese fan shells. Served with dyno sauce and choice of side.
Substitute with shrimp
Grouper Polynesian Boat 36
Blackened grouper filet, garlic parmesan risotto, and seasonal vegetables served in a pineapple boat. Choice of chili mango or sweet Thai chili sauce.
Grouper Dinner 34
Fresh grouper filet (blackened, grilled, or fried) served with choice of two sides.
Grouper Nuggets Dinner 32
Fresh battered grouper nuggets served with tartar sauce and choice of two sides.
Kids
Cheese Quesadilla
Corn Dog
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Mac and Cheese
Grilled Cheese
Cheeseburger
Pizza
Fish N Chips
Fried Shrimp
Chicken Chunks
PB and J (upon request)
Sides
Fries, Apple Sauce, Veggies,
Coleslaw, +5 Side Salad,
+5 Mac and Cheese
Add Ons
Color Changing Cup 2.50
Kids Slushie 3
Slushie Refill 3
Drink Menu
Specialty Drinks
Coastal Colada 15
Our version of the frozen classic, made with Cruzan coconut rum and a dark rum floater. It’s a perfect combination, like piña coladas and tropical beaches.
Lemon Berry Catch 15
Catch a buzz with this fan favorite, made with local Pure Culture vodka, fresh lemons, mixed berries, and topped with Sprite.
UG Rum Runner 16
Embark on a voyage with our enhanced take on this classic tropical drink, crafted with Cruzan coconut rum, banana and blackberry liqueur, tropical juices, topped off with a dark rum floater.
A.M.I. Sunset 15
Chill out with our frozen specialty:
Cruzan silver rum, strawberry & mango puree. Experience the unbeatable taste
of the island’s sunset!
Anna Maria Mule 18
Double shot of local Pure Culture vodka, key lime juice, blood orange syrup, and Gosling’s ginger beer. It’s like enjoying a taste of your favorite sun-soaked island getaway.
UG Perfect Margarita 18
Crafted with Tres Generaciones, Cointreau, Filthy margarita mix, and topped with a Grand Marnier floater.
Reposado +1, Añejo +2
Mango, Strawberry +1
Add fresh jalapeño +2
Skinny Mama-Rita 18
Enjoy a double serving of Agua Sol reposado tequila, muddled limes and oranges, a hint of agave, soda, and a Tajín rim. Add fresh jalapeño +2
Mermaid Mojito 15
Rest your fins and sip! Made with fresh mint, lime, Cruzan silver rum, and your choice of flavor: classic, coconut, mango, or strawberry.
Forbidden Paloma 15
21 Seeds hibiscus tequila, St. Germain elderflower, Filthy paloma mix, topped with soda and salt or Tajín rim.
Sunkissed Lemonade 15
A beach bar favorite featuring citron vodka, strawberry puree, and fresh squeezed lemons.
Big Ugly Bloody Mary 18
There’s the good, the bad, and then there’s the Big Ugly! Crafted with Filthy Bloody Mary mix and a double shot of Tito’s vodka, Tajín rim, and served with a hefty Bloody Mary garnish. Add spicy kick +2
Beer
Domestics
Yuengling
Miller Lite
Michelob Ultra
Bud Light
Budweiser
Imports
Stella Artois
Strongbow Cider
Corona Light
Corona Extra
Guinness
Seltzers
White Claws: Mango, Black Cherry, Raspberry.
Nutrl: Orange, Pineapple, Watermelon, Black Cherry
Suncruisers:
Classic Tea, Lemonade, Pink Lemonade
N/A
Budweiser N/A
Corona N/A
Sun King Ale N/A
Craft Beer
Kona Longboard
Island lager 4.6% ABV Kailua Kona, HI
Coppertail Night Swim
American porter 6.2% ABV
Tampa, FL
Draft Beer
3 Daughters Cider
Raspberry lemonade dry cider 5.5% ABV St. Petersburg, FL
Orange Blossom Pilsner
American pilsner 5.5%
Orlando, FL
All Draft Beers are served in 16 oz aluminum cups, 7 Domestic and 9.50 Craft
All drafts subject to change, ask your server.
Ugly Blonde Ale
Blonde ale, light, clean, and crisp
4.6% ABV, Riverview, FL
Sun King Pachanga
Wheat beer blanche 5.2% ABV Sarasota, FL
Motorworks Seasonal
Ask your server, Bradenton, FL
UG Hazy IPA
New England IPA mango hazy
7% ABV Ft. Myers, FL
Calusa Zote IPA
New England IPA hazy 7.5% ABV Sarasota, FL
Jai Alai
American IPA 7.5% ABV
Tampa, FL
Kona Big Wave
Golden ale 4.4% ABV Kailua Kona, HI
3 Daughters Rod Bender
Amber ale 5.9% ABV
St. Petersburg, FL
Allagash White
Ask your server, Portland, ME
Wine
Reds
Reds (6 oz / 10 oz)
Josh Cellars Cabernet 11 | 15
A to Z Pinot Noir 12 | 16
House
(CK Mondavi)
Pinot Grigio, Chardonnay, Merlot, Cabernet, White Zinfandel
Bubbles
Ruffino Prosecco Split 14
Josh Cellars Prosecco 50 Bottle
House Brut 28 Bottle
Veuve Clicquot 85 Bottle
Sangria
Ask about our house-made sangria (red or white).
Whites
(6 oz / 10 oz)
Ruffino Pinot Grigio 10 | 14
Kendall-Jackson Chardonnay 11 | 15
Cupcake Moscato 10 | 14
Kim Crawford Sauvignon Blanc 11 | 15
Seaglass Rosé 11 | 15
Zero Proof Cocktials N/A
Spicy Pineapple Margarita 13
Ritual zero-proof tequila, muddled jalapeños, organic agave, Filthy margarita mix, pineapple juice, and a chili lime rim.
Add Casamigos jalapeño infused tequila +6
Berry Smash 12
Mixed berries, fresh lemon juice, simple syrup, topped with Sprite and mint.
Add vodka or gin for an upcharge.
Seedlip Eastside 12
A perennial favorite made with mint, cucumber, and lime. Seedlip 108 adds complexity just like gin—you won’t miss the alcohol.
Add vodka or gin for an upcharge.
Zero Proof Specialty Cocktails
Mojito: Classic, strawberry, mango,
coconut, and Dragonberry.
AMI Sunset
Sunkissed Lemonade
Coastal Colada
Strawberry Dockiri
Miami Vice
Big Ugly Mary
Grouper-Rita: lime, mango, or strawberry
